For years Iāve heard the ad slogan, āThereās no wrong way to eat a Reeseās Peanut Butter Cup.ā Well, apparently last night I found one. I was arrested for the way I ate candy. All Iām allowed to say is that it involved a Reeseās Peanut Butter Cup, two finger puppets and a loofa sponge. And as I told the authorities, the loofa sponge was alive when I left.